Baseball betting NY

Are you a fan of pro baseball? Baseball betting in New York is gaining popularity. With more and more states legalizing sports betting, there’s never been a better time to get in on the action.

This article will show you which sportsbooks are the best for baseball betting in NY. We’ll also cover betting markets, tips to get you started, and some frequently asked questions.

Best NY baseball betting sites 2024

DraftKings Baseball betting NY DraftKings Sportsbook Bet $5, get $150 in bonus bets
  • Same game parlay boosts
  • Multiple in-game bonuses
Bet now DraftKings Sportsbook NY
BetRivers Baseball betting NY BetRivers Sportsbook 2nd Chance Bet up to $100
  • Great bonus terms
  • Excellent loyalty program
Bet now BetRivers Sportsbook NY
Caesars Sportsbook Baseball betting NY Caesars Sportsbook Up to $1,250 bonus Bet now Caesars Sportsbook NY
FanDuel Baseball betting NY FanDuel Sportsbook No Sweat First Bet Up To $1,000 Bet now FanDuel Sportsbook NY
BetMGM Baseball betting NY BetMGM Sportsbook Best odds
  • Free live streams
  • Early Cashout feature
Bet now BetMGM Sportsbook NY
PointsBet Baseball betting NY PointsBet Sportsbook Up to 5 x $100 in Bet Credits Bet now PointsBet NY review
WynnBET Baseball betting NY WynnBET Sportsbook Bet $100, get $5 in bet credits Bet now WynnBET Sportsbook NY

Hitting the dugout with NY baseball betting

Everyone likes winning big, but the true satisfaction of betting on NY baseball comes from reading the stats, learning the strategies, and understanding the odds. We’ll give you some of those tools and more in this article. You’ll have all the resources you need to get started winning some real money action.

Learning how to bet on baseball isn’t easy. In this guide to online baseball betting in New York, we’ll lead you down the path to betting profitability. That means we’ll cover the following:

Which sportsbooks offer the best baseball betting picks

  • What types of baseball markets you should check out
  • Some of the common mistakes people make are
  • …and how to avoid them.

When you finish reading this guide, we’re confident you’ll be on the right track to a winning baseball betting strategy. You’ll be ready to leave the dugout and hit the sportsbook.

Great sportsbooks for New York baseball betting

You know you’ve stumbled upon a good sportsbook when it gives you access to a massive roster of sports and betting choices. After all, it’s essential to give some thought to where you will be doing your online sports betting in New York.

To that end, we’ve compiled a list of the best sportsbooks for New York baseball betting. These are among the top sportsbooks in the state and carry some of the best baseball betting odds and markets.

BetMGM Baseball betting

Betting on baseball at BetMGM NY puts you in the capable hands of one of the biggest betting brands in the country. The brand has an excellent reputation, and its platform, markets, and bonus structures are among the best.

Caesars baseball odds

The betting lines at Caesars Sportsbook NY app are some of the best on the east coast. They also have a great selection of baseball picks and parlays.

Betrivers baseball betting

Betrivers NY deserves a top spot on this list on account of its fantastic baseball odds. Not only that, but they’re a reputable NY gambling site, fully licensed, and offer great rewards to players who stick around.

DraftKings baseball sportsbook

DraftKings New York needs no introduction. They have excellent betting markets in just about every sport, and baseball is no different. The offers an abundance of prop bets. Meaning it’s the perfect choice for the more advanced bettor to implement their betting strategy.

FanDuel baseball betting lines

FanDuel NY Sportsbook has great baseball betting options and is one of the best mobile apps around. If mobile betting (and convenience) is a priority for you, this is the place to park your baseball betting picks.

Bonuses and promos for NY baseball betting


Every site on the above list offers some lucrative bonuses and promos for New York baseball betting. These can take different forms depending on the sportsbook and whether you’ve gambled there before.

Let’s look at some of the most common betting bonuses in New York typically handed out by sportsbooks. If you’re getting started with sports betting, it can benefit you to shop around and find a sign-up bonus.

I would not recommend using it as the deciding factor of which sportsbook you use. However, do consider them when you have multiple quality sportsbooks offering copious NY baseball betting options.

Deposit bonuses

These deposit bonuses for baseball betting in NY are only available upon depositing a certain amount at a particular time. The most common form of deposit bonus is typically given out as a sign-up bonus.

The sportsbook site will match you dollar for dollar up to two or three hundred dollars in a deposit bonus. The total amount depends on the sportsbook and how much you are willing to lay down on day one.

Insurance bonus bet

They say there is no such thing as an insurance bonus bet at baseball betting in NY, but whoever said that has never gambled at an online sportsbook. There, insurance bonus bets are a standard promo offer.

In New York, insurance bonus baseball bets allow you to wager a specific amount more than once. If you lose, the sportsbook will enable you to recoup your amount each time in the form of credits to try again.

Benefits of online New York baseball betting


There are many advantages to placing your NY baseball wagers online vs. at a physical location. Here are a few of the top benefits of online baseball betting.

1. Plenty of promos

Online sportsbooks are a new thing in New York. You can bet there’s going to be plenty of promos to bring in new customers. Online betting gives you access to bonus bets, odds boosts, deposit matches, and bets exclusive to MLB.

2. Live streaming, live betting

All good sportsbooks offer live betting in New York. It’s massively lucrative and has high entertainment value. Baseball is one of the most popular sports for live betting. Live streaming, on the other hand, is not something every New York sportsbook is offering yet. Check for details on the individual sportsbook page.

3. Plenty of betting markets

Physical locations do not give you the same volume or variety of betting markets as online sports betting sites. Baseball markets are no exceptions. Using New York’s top online sportsbooks gives you access to your favorite bets and then some right from your pocket.

Betting markets for New York baseball


The Yankees and the Mets are well served by the betting options available at most New York online sportsbooks. There will be plenty of choices available to the New York baseball bettor, and here we’ll go over the different kinds of bets you can make.

Why is this important? Knowing the different kinds of bets allows you to delve into additional revenue streams. It also lets you get the most value out of your predictions. Knowing the options helps you choose the right baseball betting strategy.


In baseball, the Moneyline focuses on which player or team will win the game.

Here’s an example: an oddsmaker lists the Yankees as -170 on the Moneyline, and Miami is listed as +150. This means the Yankees are the favored team, and Miami is the underdog. A $100 bet on Miami would net $150, where’s $170 is required on the Yankees just to break $100.


In baseball betting, totals track of the run-scorer of a game. The oddsmaker sets a number, and you get to bet whether the run-score will be over or under what the oddsmaker sets. If you’re right, you win. Simple as that.


Parlays are like a bouquet of bets. It’s a package of bets all wrapped into one big wager. You need to succeed on every item in the parley, though, or else you’ll lose the whole bet.

Here’s an example: you could parley that both the Mets and the Blue Jays will both win their next game. They would both need to win their games for you to win your bet.


Futures are one of the more common bets that most people know about outside of betting on the Moneyline. It’s a simple concept to grasp: do you think the Mets will win the World Series?

Placing a wager on that would constitute a futures bet. You have to be pretty confident about your decision, though. It also helps to time your futures bet to take advantage of knowledge gained throughout the season.

Prop bets

Prop is short for proposition, and these bets can be a lot of fun. It helps to think of them as novelty bets. Oddsmakers will specify specific outcomes related to the players or events that occur in the game itself.

Whether a particular player will break their run record. Whether the Yankees will break their win percentage for the current season. These are some examples of prop bets in New York you that can wager on.

Live betting

Live betting in New York is where all the real money action is, and Baseball betting is no exception in this trend. Live bets are dynamic. The odds are in constant flux, adding an extra dimension to watching your favorite games live. Most sportsbooks worth their salt are heavily promoting live bets. Give it a try at one of the excellent ones listed above. Other sports markets to bet on:

Three ways to avoid common NY baseball betting mistakes


Everyone makes mistakes. But the stakes a high when you placing wagers, so it’s essential to know the pitfalls. Below are a few easy solutions to some of the most common betting mistakes:

  • Not knowing the player lineup
  • Betting on favorites too often
  • Mismanaging your bankroll

1. Know the players in the lineup

This is an integral part of being a competent bettor. If you don’t know the team you’re betting on, you shouldn’t be placing that wager. Unless you are really sure you can afford to lose. Getting to know the lineup playing in the game you’re betting on – particularly the starting pitcher – can significantly impact your baseball betting strategy.

Consider this: you’re betting on New York (whose record is 4-11) vs. Toronto (10-5). Those numbers tell you that you should undoubtedly consider the starting pitcher in New York when wagering on the outcome.

2. Bet on the underdog

Baseball is a bit unlike other sports in that the gap between the best and the worst is narrower. Even the best teams lose about a third of their games across the season.

Betting on your favorites is not a good strategy for two big reasons. The first I just mentioned: your favorite team is going to lose nearly as often as they are going to win. The more losses for you, the better.

Another reason is that doing a little research and placing a well-informed bet on the underdog can result in massive winnings. Underdogs are valued at more per bet than the favorites. You often lose money betting on your favorites.

3. Manage your bankroll

This one is important. The fast way to lose when you are ahead is to get greedy. Staying on top of your finances, your strategy, and your self-control is critical. If you are winning, stop while you are ahead. Set a budget for each betting session and stick to it.

FAQ’s About Baseball betting New York

How do you bet on New York baseball?

Now that it’s legal in the state, it’s easy to bet on baseball in New York. Check out one of the sportsbooks listed above. Sign up and make your deposit. You’ll be betting in no time. Review the info in this article for strategies and tips to make your wagers go further.

Is it legal to bet on New York baseball?

New Yorkers have watched as state after state has legalized online sports betting. Now they can join the fray with fully legal, licensed baseball betting with real money action.

What is live betting, and can I live bet on baseball?

Live betting is a popular form of betting. It lets you bet on in-game action as it’s happening on the field. You have to be astute, though and know your stuff. The odds are constantly changing. And yes, live betting is available on NY baseball.

What is the best way to deposit NY baseball betting funds?

A good sports betting site will offer plenty of deposit options, from credit and checking to Paypal, Paynearme, and prepared cards like Play+. Just head over to the deposit page on your favorite sportsbook, choose the amount, method, and the transaction will be ready in just a few seconds.

How can I get my baseball betting winnings?

There aren’t as many options when it comes to withdrawing your winnings. Most sportsbooks will deposit directly via e-check into your bank account or send you a physical check. This can sometimes take a few business days to go through.